The Best Restaurants in The Caribbean

Many factors influence our decision on the best restaurant. Our top choices are food, service, and ambiance. Recognizing that each of these islands has a unique dish, we have tried to be as inclusive as possible. Although there are so many top eateries that this list is inexhaustive, our selection is exclusive to those that have distinguished themselves.

In the heydays of luxury Caribbean dining, Graycliff was among the first 5-star restaurants in the region. Graycliff is a Nassau landmark built by a notorious Caribbean pirate and later used as a church and garrison.

Caribbean Fish Market is an elegant indoor-outdoor restaurant located at the Elysian Beach Resort in St. Thomas island, within walking distance of the Ritz Carlton.

At the top of the Limesgrove Lifestyle Complex is an indoor rooftop restaurant with a stunning view of the ocean and Barbados island. Located in Holetown, a small city on Barbados’s west coast, this restaurant’s modern, lounge-like space and retractable walls stand out.

Zimbali’s Mountain Cooking Studio is a must for lovers of food. The restaurant, located a short distance from Montego Bay, is unique at making its guests play an active role in the meal’s creation. A typical afternoon or evening at Zimbali’s begins with a farm tour followed by a cooking demonstration. Guests then engage in a three-course meal that changes seasonally with what’s available on the farm. 

Ocean 82 is an indoor-outdoor dining overlooking the Baie de Grand Case and the horizon beyond. The ideal time to visit Ocean 82 is at sunset. Unsurprisingly, seafood is the focus of this diner. Signature dishes include the lobster thermidor, sesame-crusted tuna steak, Mahi Mahi tartare trilogy, and tuna spring rolls. The wine is predominantly from France.

Passions on the Beach is located directly on the sand at Amsterdam Manor on Eagle Beach. This ambience elegant restaurant is as tropical as it can be. Live music sets the tone and accompanies a dinner packed with fresh seafood and plenty of vegetarian options.

The Landing restaurant is interestingly a restored boat that serves up some of the best drinks on the island. Surrounded by sand and open sky, the Landing offers a picturesque setting with lounges, string lights, and a fire pit ideal for a drink before or after a meal.

The best restaurants in the Caribbean offer more than just food. They offer a taste of their local culture, whetting not just your appetite but your curiosity, urging you to explore. Our restaurant choices will make your journey into the Caribbean more interesting. Every bite feels like a taste of the essence of these remarkable islands. Like the region itself, they are an otherworldly fusion of cultures and cuisines, celebrated mixology, and the musical ambiance unique to the Caribbean.

Tour these restaurants in grand style with Boatsters luxury yacht charter for a true feel of the Caribbean. Dine, fish, explore the treasured reefs and check off your Caribbean to-do list in a once in a lifetime adventure.